Details
-
Type:
RFC
-
Status: Implemented
-
Resolution: Done
-
Component/s: DM
-
Labels:None
Description
Since the acceptance of RFC-356 and RFC-289 (and maybe another I haven't found?) selected maggies as DM's calibrated flux unit, the Project Science Team has landed firmly on janskies (Jy) as the unit for calibrated fluxes in public LSST data products, with a further note that nano-janskies (nJy) put many relevant quantities for LSST in a nice range for humans to reason about and remember. For more information, see https://pstn-001.lsst.io/.
I can't think of a good reason for DM's internal calibrated flux unit to be something different, and I can certainly imagine ways in which being different could cause problems (probably minor ones, but then there's the Mars Climate Orbiter...).
So I hereby propose that all DM code and intermediate data products use nJy for calibrated fluxes, and that we drop usage of maggies entirely.
This does not mean that we should convert instrumental fluxes in images or catalogs to calibrated fluxes as soon as a calibration is available; on the contrary, we should work in instrumental fluxes and maintain the calibration (the mapping from counts to nJy) in a separate, more lightweight form (i.e. Calib and PhotoCalib) as long as possible. This avoids frequent re-calibration of images and catalogs as the mapping from instrumental to calibrated fluxes improves over the course of pipeline execution. We currently continue to use instrumental fluxes even through coaddition and coadd processing, and while I think I'm open to switching to calibrated fluxes earlier, that should be discussed on a different RFC (possibly RFC-545).
Attachments
Issue Links
- blocks
-
DM-17018 deprecate and disable ScaleZeroPointTask
- To Do
- is triggering
-
DM-16650 Use nJy in PhotoCalib as the unit for calibrated fluxes
- Done
-
DM-17029 Update LoadReferenceObjectsTask to output fluxes in nanojansky
- Done
-
DM-19970 Update Flux descriptions and units in schema
- Invalid
-
RFC-575 Convert old refcats to nJy for RFC-549
- Implemented
- relates to
-
DM-11044 Create reference docs for reference catalog schema
- Invalid
-
RFC-356 Provide reference catalog fluxes in Maggies
- Retired
-
RFC-545 Deprecate ScaleZeroPointTask
- Adopted
-
RFC-289 New spatially-variant PhotoCalib object
- Implemented
-
DM-34797 Bring ref,sci images to the same unit -- during training of networks
- Done
Jim Bosch what's the status of this RFC?
(also "nanojansky" not "nanoJansky" since we don't say "kiloMeter" or "nanoVolts"...)